November 20, 2026

Estate administration: What happens when executors cannot agree?

It is common for more than one executor to be named in a Will, and where there are multiple executors, they are jointly responsible for administering the estate. However, when multiple people are involved in the administration of an estate, this can lead to conflict, particularly where the executors have differing opinions about how the estate should be managed, or where the dynamic between the named executors is already difficult.

But what happens when executors cannot agree, and what options are there for resolution?

The consequences of disagreement between executors

The administration of an estate can be complex and involves a number of decisions being made. Where there is more than one executor, disagreements can arise for a variety of reasons, including:

  • whether an estate property or other asset should be sold;
  • the value attributed to particular assets;
  • how the terms of the Will should be interpreted;
  • the timing of distributions to beneficiaries;
  • whether professional advice is needed and, if so, which professionals should be instructed;
  • whether legal proceedings should be commenced, defended or settled;
  • where executors are also beneficiaries, disagreements may arise because a particular decision could benefit one beneficiary at the expense of another, creating a potential conflict between their personal interests and their duties as executors.

If executors are unable to reach agreement, this can lead to a deadlock which prevents the estate administration from progressing.

Delays can have a number of consequences, including increased administration costs, additional interest or financial penalties (particularly in relation to tax liabilities), depreciation in the value of estate assets and missed opportunities to sell assets at a favourable price. Beneficiaries may also become frustrated by the delay in receiving their inheritance, potentially leading to further complaints or disputes.

Executors have legal duties with which they must comply when administering an estate. An executor who fails to fulfil those duties, acts unreasonably or causes loss to the estate may face allegations of breach of duty, personal liability or an application for their removal. It is therefore important that disagreements are addressed promptly and that the administration is not allowed to become unnecessarily delayed.

Practical methods of resolving disputes

There are a number of practical steps that can be taken to try to resolve disagreements between executors without the need for court proceedings:

  • Open communication

    In some cases, disagreements can be resolved through better communication. Discussing the issues openly, understanding the other executor’s concerns and considering the options available may help the executors reach an agreement.

  • Instructing a professional

    Independent professional advice can help clarify the executors’ duties and the options available. A solicitor experienced in estate administration may be able to advise on a particular issue and help the executors find a way forward.

  • One executor stepping down

    An executor who no longer wishes to be involved may be able to renounce their appointment, provided they have not intermeddled in the estate. Alternatively, where another executor obtains the Grant, power may be reserved to an executor who does not initially wish to take part, allowing them to apply for a Grant at a later stage. However, one executor stepping down will not necessarily resolve the underlying disagreement.

  • Mediation

    Mediation provides an opportunity for executors to discuss their differences with the assistance of an independent mediator. It can be particularly useful where the executors have a difficult personal relationship but remain willing to consider a compromise.

When a court application might be necessary

Where practical steps have failed to resolve the disagreement, it may be necessary to ask the court to intervene.

Depending on the nature of the dispute, an application may be made for directions from the court on a particular issue. For example, the executors may require guidance on the interpretation of a Will or whether a particular estate asset should be sold.

In more serious cases, it may be appropriate to seek the removal of one or more executors and their replacement with an independent person. Section 50 of the Administration of Justice Act 1985 gives the court power to remove or substitute personal representatives in appropriate circumstances.

An independent administrator is a neutral third party, often a solicitor or professional, appointed to take responsibility for administering the estate. This can be an effective solution where the relationship between the executors has broken down to such an extent that the administration cannot realistically continue with them in place.

However, disagreement between executors will not, by itself, necessarily justify their removal. The court will consider the circumstances as a whole and whether intervention is appropriate in the interests of the proper administration of the estate.

You can read more about the appointment of independent administrators in our article below.

How can RWK Goodman help?

Disagreements between executors can make an already complex estate administration more difficult and time-consuming. Where disputes cannot be resolved, specialist legal advice can help identify the options available and determine whether court intervention is necessary.

RWK Goodman has extensive experience advising executors, beneficiaries and other interested parties in contentious estate administrations. We can advise on resolving disagreements, applications for directions, the removal of executors and the appointment of independent administrators. Our associated trust company, Withy King Trustees Limited (WKTL), is also regularly appointed to act as an independent administrator where appropriate.

Looking for support with estate administration and executor disputes?

Whether you’re looking to resolve an executor dispute, or need an independent administrator, our specialist solicitors are here to help.

Call now

Find out more

More insights from our experts.

View more articles related to Inheritance Disputes and Wills, Trusts and Estates