Ofsted’s new approach to fines for unregistered children’s social care: what providers need to know
In October this year, Ofsted published new guidance explaining how it will impose and calculate monetary penalties where children’s social care is carried on or managed without registration.
The message is clear: operating a registrable establishment or agency without registration is an offence and the financial consequences can be significant. However, the guidance also sets out a structured process for deciding whether, and at what level, a penalty should be imposed, including opportunities to make representations and appeal.
Fines are an alternative enforcement route to prosecution
Section 11 of the Care Standards Act 2000 makes it an offence to carry on or manage a children’s social care establishment or agency without registration.
Section 29 gives Ofsted the power to prosecute and, more recently, section 30ZC(2) (inserted by the Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Act 2026) gives Ofsted the power to impose monetary penalties.
The new civil penalty regime sits alongside, rather than replaces, Ofsted’s existing prosecution powers. Recent enforcement action demonstrates that Ofsted is willing to pursue criminal proceedings where it considers this appropriate, as discussed in our article, Ofsted prosecutes unregistered children’s home provider, imposing a significant fine. The regulator has indicated that it will continue to prosecute where it has concerns about children’s safety.
Before issuing a penalty, Ofsted must be satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that a person or organisation was carrying on or managing provision which should have been registered. It may then issue a Notice of Intention to impose a monetary penalty. The recipient has 28 days to make written representations, after which a Fine Advisory Panel considers the proposed penalty. If a penalty notice is issued, there is a further 28-day right of appeal to the First-tier Tribunal, which may confirm, cancel or reduce the penalty.
How will Ofsted calculate a fine?
For organisations, the process begins with two key questions: how culpable was the provider and what harm, or risk of harm, was caused to children?
Culpability ranges from very high, where the law was intentionally breached or flagrantly disregarded, to low, which can include cases where reasonable efforts were made to register or failings were minor and isolated.
Harm is divided into four categories, ranging from Category 1, where a child has suffered harm, to Category 4, where there was a low risk of harm. Importantly, Ofsted distinguishes between actual harm and risk of harm. Where there was risk but no actual harm, or less serious harm, it will usually move the case into a lower category.
The organisation is then placed into one of four financial bands based on the fees paid by local authorities in connection with the offending provision, rather than overall turnover. The organisation’s size, culpability and level of harm determine the starting point for the penalty.
That figure is not fixed. Aggravating and mitigating factors may move it up or down. Where evidence of fees is unavailable, Ofsted may use alternative evidence and the circumstances of the case to make a reasonable estimate.
Individuals may also be personally exposed
Monetary penalties are not confined to organisations and are not limited to registered managers. The guidance defines an “individual” as a person whom Ofsted considers to have carried on and/or managed an unregistered social care setting or provision.
In practice, Ofsted is likely to look beyond job titles and corporate structures to identify who exercised day-to-day control, made operational decisions and assumed responsibility for the provision of care.
‘Individual’ penalties range from a starting point of £2,750 (£2,400-£5,500 range) for low culpability and Category 4 harm, up to a starting point of £40,000 (£20,000-£80,000 range) for very high culpability and Category 1 harm.
Risks of accepting a civil penalty
A civil penalty may appear less serious than a criminal prosecution, but providers should treat any notice from Ofsted with equal care. Accepting a civil penalty is likely to involve an acknowledgement of an offence or breach and may affect future registration, commissioning relationships, reputation and standing with local authorities. It is not simply a fine to be paid and forgotten.
Providers should seek legal advice before responding to Ofsted, providing information or accepting a proposed penalty. They should also preserve commissioning records, local authority correspondence and safeguarding documentation from the outset, particularly where a placement arose because no suitable registered provision was available. Such evidence may be important to the outcome of any investigation or enforcement action.
The key takeaway
The new guidance makes the financial consequences of operating unregistered children’s social care much clearer. Providers, directors and individuals who receive a Notice of Intention should seek legal advice promptly, particularly given the 28-day deadline for representations and the subsequent 28-day appeal period. There may be important arguments about whether registration was required, who was responsible for carrying on or managing the service, the level of culpability, the existence and extent of any harm or risk, the appropriate penalty band, and the availability of mitigation. The representations process provides an important opportunity to challenge both the basis of Ofsted’s proposed action and the level of any proposed penalty.
RWK Goodman
Our team supports children’s home providers, supported accommodation providers, and social care organisations in navigating complex regulatory issues, responding to Ofsted investigations, and challenging decisions where appropriate.